Inter Partes Review: Challenging Amended Claims

By Michael Ginsberg An Inter Partes Review (IPR) is a procedure for challenging the validity of a United States patent and is conducted by the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB). Under Section 311(b) of the Patent Act, someone may only challenge a patent using an IPR only under the grounds that could be raised under 35 U.S.C. Section 102 (which generally relates to when an invention is already public) or Section 103 (which provides that a patentable invention must not have been obvious to a “person having ordinary skill in the art”). Additionally, the challenge can be made only based on the existence of a prior art. A patent owner can amend their patent claims for reexamination if their patent is found to be ineligible under an IPR and the reexamination would once again be an IPR conducted by the PTAB. In the case, Amazon.com Inc. v. Uniloc Luxembourg SA, Amazon challenged and filed for an IPR for claims 1-25 for

read more Inter Partes Review: Challenging Amended Claims

Fourth Estate Public Benefit Corporation v. Wall-Street.com

Copyright owners cannot sue for infringement until the Copyright Office has granted registration by Michael Ginsberg The U.S. Supreme Court on March 4, 2019 announced a unanimous decision in Fourth Estate Public Benefit Corporation v. Wall-Street.com, 586 US _ (2019) that a copyright owner must wait for registration from the Copyright Office before being able to claim infringement in court. Fourth Estate is a news organization that produces online journalism and licenses its articles to other websites while maintaining the copyrights for these articles. Fourth Estate and Wall-Street.com came to a licensing agreement that allowed Wall-Street.com to obtain the licenses to several articles produced by Fourth Estate. Under this agreement, Wall-Street was required to remove all content produced by Fourth Estate from their website if Wall Street were to cancel the arrangement. However, when Wall-Street cancelled the licensing arrangement with Fourth Estate, they did not remove the content from their website, triggering Fourth Estate to sue for copyright infringement. Yet, although Fourth Estate

read more Fourth Estate Public Benefit Corporation v. Wall-Street.com

The U.S. Joins the Marrakesh Treaty

By Michael Ginsberg The landmark Treaty allows VIPs (Visually Impaired People) access to copies of books President Donald J. Trump signed the documents for the U.S. to ratify the Marrakesh Treaty on January 28   , 2019 and the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) has welcomed the recent ratification. The Treaty requires those involved to create exceptions to typical copyright rules in order to make published works in formats that VIPs (Visually Impaired People) would be able to read. Additionally it permits exchanging these works across borders by organizations that serve these VIPs. The definition of “works” within the Treaty is limited to materials in the form of text, notation and/or related illustration (including audiobooks). Works that fall within the scope of the Treaty must be publicly available in any media. An important element of the Treaty is the role played by authorized organizations which are the organizations in charge of providing the services to VIPs. The Marrakesh Treaty

read more The U.S. Joins the Marrakesh Treaty

News Release: U.S. Ratification of the Marrakesh Treaty

https://www.uspto.gov/about-us/news-updates/us-ratification-marrakesh-treaty U.S. ratification of the Marrakesh TreatyLandmark treaty facilitates accessible copies of books to persons who are blind, visually impaired, and print disabled WASHINGTON – The United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) welcomed the recent ratification of the Marrakesh Treaty, which allows limited copyright exceptions for the reproduction of published works in formats accessible to the blind and visually impaired. President Donald J. Trump signed the documents for the U.S. to ratify the Marrakesh Treaty to Facilitate Access to Published Works for Persons Who Are Blind, Visually Impaired, or Otherwise Print Disabled on January 28, 2019. Follow link above for full news release.

Regulating Blockchain: A New Challenge for Society

As a fifth and last post on this blog series regarding blockchain, Stein IP introduces “Regulating Blockchain: A New Challenge for Society” As known and explained on our previous posts, Blockchain is a growing technology that promises to streamline processes, clarify transactions and avoid third parties interventions and costs. Moreover, it’s better known as the platform where Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are processed, which triggered governments and regulatory agencies to  realize that a lot of the money involved in financial transactions worldwide was carried out using these kinds of digital currencies. Along with this, in some cases this money was used to fund certain illegal activities. Due to this, countries all around the globe have started issuing regulations to control Blockchain technology. Below there are some examples of regulations in different countries on Blockchain technology: European Union On May 25, the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) issued a regulation that allows users to delete personal information on a Blockchain network.

read more Regulating Blockchain: A New Challenge for Society

Winton Machine Co. Wins Many Business Awards

Winton Machine Co., based in Suwanee, Georgia and one of our oldest clients has won the following awards over the past 3 years.  The attorneys of Stein IP are very proud to serve the IP needs of this growing company. Georgia Small Business ROCK STAR Award Nominee 2019 Gwinnett Chamber Pinnacle Overall Small Business Award 2018 Gwinnett Chamber Pinnacle Small Business 25+ Employees Award 2018 U.S. Commercial Service Export Achievement Award 2017 GLOBE (Georgia Launching Opportunities By Exporting) Award 2017, Global Atlanta Atlanta Metro Export Challenge (MEC) 2017 grant recipient as semi-finalist and finalist Women in Business Champion of the Year – Lisa Winton, National Small Business Week in Georgia 2017 Partnership Gwinnett – Movers & Makers Awards – Small Manufacturer of the Year 2015

Blockchain And IP Law

As a fourth post on this blog series regarding blockchain, Stein IP introduces “Blockchain and IP Law.” Due to Blockchain is frequently related with Bitcoin exclusively, people might think Intellectual Property (‘IP’) Law and Blockchain are incompatible or perhaps never thought of a potential combination of these two. But what if we were able to trace an intellectual property right from its beginnings? Seems like Blockchain may have the answer to that question and many others, opening a wide range of opportunities where IP Law proceeds. First of all, Blockchain could help fix IP registration system inefficiencies. In the United States, according to the US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), it takes more than a year to take action after a filing because a lot of applications are subject to manual review, resulting in the total length of time from filing to completing the registration to be 2 years in most cases. This is a real problem if we talk

read more Blockchain And IP Law

Winton Machine Co., one of Stein IP’s clients, wins two Small Business Pinnacle Awards

The Gwinnett (Ga.) Chamber of Commerce Small Business Pinnacle Awards pays tribute to the leading small businesses that take the chance to start, strive to sustain and persevere to succeed. This year, thirteen businesses and entrepreneurs were awarded for their extraordinary achievements and pivotal role in the county’s economic growth and stability. Winton Machine Company, one of Stein IP LLC’s oldest clients, attended the Small Business Pinnacle Awards on Wednesday, October 17th 2018 and was awarded recognition for being the “Small Business of the Year” in the categories of 25+ Employees and the Best Overall. Our client specializes in providing engineered solutions in major industries, such as HVAC/Refrigeration, Aerospace, Furniture, Electronics, Automotive Aftermarket and Military. Although the company started in the owner’s home basement in 1997, within a year it quickly grew to a basement machine shop filled with equipment and supplies. A few short months later, Winton Machine received its initial machinery order and the company moved into its

read more Winton Machine Co., one of Stein IP’s clients, wins two Small Business Pinnacle Awards

A New Measure In the Electronic Retrieval Method for Priority Documents between USPTO and KIPO

There has been a change, effective December 1, 2018, on how documents are electronically retrieved between the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) and the Korean Intellectual Property Office (KIPO). From that date on, electronic retrievals of priority documents between the USPTO and KIPO will be managed via the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) Digital Access Service (DAS). By notification on April 20, 2009, the USPTO expanded its PDX (Electronic Priority Document Exchange) program by agreement with the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) to participate in the multilateral exchange of certain priority documents with other IP offices participating in the WIPO Digital Access Service (DAS) for Priority Documents. DAS is a service currently provided by WIPO that offers a simple and safe digital alternative to filing paper copies of priority documents with multiple IP Offices. It enables an applicant claiming priority to ask Offices of second filing to retrieve a copy of the priority document themselves via the service.

read more A New Measure In the Electronic Retrieval Method for Priority Documents between USPTO and KIPO

How Is The World Using Blockchain?

As a third post on this blog series regarding blockchain, Stein IP introduces “How is the world using blockchain?” In our previous two posts we have explained what blockchain is and how it affects businesses, in this post we will be talking about the different uses blockchain has or can potentially have in different sectors. From financial services, to voting, to healthcare, blockchain has many applications to today’s world and companies and individuals are starting to dive into them. Cryptocurrencies Probably the most known application of blockchain has been cryptocurrencies. Cryptocurrencies are essentially digital money, digital tools of exchange that use cryptography and with blockchain technology it can facilitate secure and anonymous transactions among users. Cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum (the two biggest cryptocurrencies of this technology) are necessary for many of the applications and transactions in blockchain. Even when writing and executing smart contracts in the network, participants in the transaction must have a cryptocurrency stake and unlike traditional markets,

read more How Is The World Using Blockchain?